Comments on: Getting Back On The Horse: How To Make A Comeback from a Japanese Hiatus /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/ You don't know a language, you live it. You don't learn a language, you get used to it. Sat, 04 Jul 2020 16:09:19 +0900 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.1.13 By: Christian Douvia /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-229756 Mon, 23 Jul 2012 06:01:19 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-229756 It’s true that a lot of kids have highly underdeveloped powers of focus these days because of Twitter and social media, but I have to acquire their side about Frankenstein… I’ve tried twice to browse this damn thing many of the way by and failed both times-it ends up on every school reading list like clockwork because it’s “literature”, and although the old black and white movies they spun off it in the 30s and 40s are great fun, it just doesn’t hold up. A few of a long time back again I heard a possibly apocryphal story about a teacher who gave his students the choice of reading Bram Stoker’s Dracula alternatively; a highly popular choice until the schoolboard was quietly leaned on by a group of parents to remove it…It was also Catholic for the fundamentalists, much too Satanic to the Catholics, and way too Godly for that small group of atheists who joined in. So now the kids should slog by way of Frankenstein and student suicides are up 50%…

]]>
By: Santiago Madrigal /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-97500 Thu, 12 May 2011 02:32:57 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-97500 Well… I was also in the very noble journey of owning Japanese and eventually becoming a trilingual translator… but I stumbled with a different project I wanted to pursue. I decided to stop reviewing my RTK kanji and the few sentences I had on my SRS. I stopped watching anime and japanese videos, trying to read websites in japanese, manga in japanese… I only listen some japanese music now.

And it’s hard to admit… but I lost all I have learned. “Use it or lose it”. But meh; whatever. I knew that would happen. And once I achieve what I want to achieve, I will re-start, from scratch, from the very beginning, from 一, from あ. But the thing is that I already knew what lies ahead… so it’s kind of an advantage.

It’s like when you borrow a game from a friend, and you get to a cetain point of it, then you return the game to your friend, and he deletes your save file just so he can see your horror face… but once you buy that game for yourself, you know what lies ahead, so you can complete it faster and arrive to the point where you were initially, but in less time.

For me it’s kind of exciting re-starting something, so the process of re-reviewing 3030 kanji again doesn’t seem painful or unfair. It’s just what it is. Don’t use it… restart the game, dude. Then… keep playing, and play it the most that you can!

So yeah, my point is: If you have a long hiatus, restart. For some it’s exciting, for others might be painful… but that’s the only option you have.

]]>
By: Lingomi’s Reading List for July 30, 2010 « Lingomi Blog /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-50479 Fri, 30 Jul 2010 15:32:33 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-50479 […] Getting Back On The Horse: How To Make A Comeback from a Japanese Hiatus […]

]]>
By: Returning To Japanese – My Thoughts | My Yaruki (やる気) /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-50468 Fri, 30 Jul 2010 10:58:08 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-50468 […] I read the post over on alljapaneseallthetime.com where Katz suggests starting from scratch just as if you where […]

]]>
By: Brent B /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49860 Sun, 25 Jul 2010 15:09:58 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49860 First off, thanks for linking my article. You inspired me a lot, and I was just tired of everyone treating the 10000 as a holy grail of sorts, and the ride didn’t count.

Also, it’s my most searched/read article 😛 Probably need to do that more, right?

Secondly, I’ve been on a break too…I’ve been not liking Japanese. However, reading this article has really made me want to get back on it…so…yeah. I’m changing my XBawks stuff into Japanese. I’ll just play Blazblue in Japanese lol

]]>
By: Dan /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49342 Wed, 21 Jul 2010 08:12:33 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49342 My SRS has stalled the last few months. I just had about 2 weeks where I didn’t look at it and felt pretty bored about going back to it.

But because I donated all my old English books to my old secondary school last year, have nothing but manga and Japanese personal development books in my room and my computer/ipod, etc, are all set to Japanese, I have still being taking it in. You can absorb Japanese even when you don’t want to. If you build the right environment it stops becoming a choice about whether or not you learn Japanese today.

Otherwise, I like to reignite my passion for Japanese by occasionally searching the net for ‘the 100 best Japanese films/comics/superheroes/computer games/comedians/blogs/podcasts Ever’. This kind of searching opens up huge areas of new fun material to splash around in.

A Japanese friend directed me to this legendary resource for free anime/films and tv kimamaniyoutube.blog78.fc2.com/

Last fm is a great lazy way to find new Japanese bands without too much effort. Just put in a band you know and the playlist will automatically skip around to similar Japanese bands. Awesome.

]]>
By: Jack /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49317 Wed, 21 Jul 2010 02:47:05 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49317 This reminds me of the Sisyphus analogy. You know, the guy who offended the gods and for so doing was punished to push a rock up a hill for all eternity, only to have the rock become so heavy near the top of the hill that it slides back down. We only start at the bottom of the hill once. Every other time, we are closer to the top of the hill than that first time. Still, we have a huge distance to go, and probably still did have a huge distance to go when we stopped pushing.

So what kind of advice to you give someone whose rock has fallen down? Push the rock up the hill. But why did they stop pushing in the first place? Does it even matter?

]]>
By: Aric /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49207 Tue, 20 Jul 2010 01:28:58 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49207 I think theres something to be said about the fact that returning after a Hiatus can be daunting. I slipped a while back, moved back in with my parents, ereader broke, computer got stolen, and kind of gave up for a while. I’m “getting back on the horse” now, it theres some stuff I forgot sure, but I just keep SRSing and its all coming back quickly.

Heres to cool part:
By stepping away from the language and coming back and seeing where you left off, you really get a outside perspective of how much you’ve done. I don’t care if its 5 sentences or 3000, you get a new view on how much you’ve achieved.

It’s not something I’d recommend, but it also isn’t the end of the world. As people have said make it fun again, and don’t try and force it all back. Take your time, enjoy yourself. Also heres one tip of what I did if you have a SRS deck piled up and are afraid of it. First, ignore the number, you owe your computer nothing, you only have to do as many as you want (atleast for now). Second, if your like me this may help, set the time for the SRS sessions to something like 60 seconds and leave the program always running, and then when ever you’re waiting for a page to load, or commercials or just bored or willing SRS for those 60 second intervals. If you want to keep going, most programs let you. You’ll be surprised at a) how much more willing you are to SRS when you only have to do it for [reasonable amount of time here] and b) how quickly the deck seems to disappear even using this method.

Thats my 2 yen, good luck and have fun.

]]>
By: Drabant /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49166 Mon, 19 Jul 2010 13:51:21 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49166 I think one problem is over ambition, especially early on. When climbing back on the horse again we have to look at what made us fall off in the first place.

I am almost done with my reboot of RTK, and doing much better this second time around than my first. So why did I fail the first time? First when I started out I wanted to get over RTK as soon as possible, to get on with the real stuff. Doing this lead to a situation where my waking time ended up being split between work and doing RTK, until I finally grew sick of it.

Instead of being fixated on how many sentences I have to add each day, I should make sure that I keep the time spent on the SRS each down so that even if I skip a day or two, it won’t feel like a chore when I catch up. Which will actually give me time for the important stuff, listening and reading.

]]>
By: Andro /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49132 Mon, 19 Jul 2010 08:24:45 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49132 I was in a similar situation. I fell off the horse and needed to restart, but considerably earlier on. As far as relearning the kanji I’d forgotten went, I just redid the RTK up to the point I’d forgotten, putting everything back into my SRS and reviewing it from the start. I’m a lot further now, so I don’t know if I’d want to know delete everything from it again and put it all in again, since it would be waaaay too much work. I’d probably just suspend all the cards created past a certain point so I could re-familiarize myself with all the earlier stuff again, and unsuspend more and more as I got further along. It was a lot easier to relearn the kanji I’d forgotten than to learn them for the very first time, so it was fun seeing how well I was doing when I first started again!

Before I got started in RTK again though, I had to overcome those, “Oh nooo I don’t know anything again I need to start from the beginning!!!” feelings I got. I had gotten over that one day by rereading one of my favorite comics which is in Japanese only and really wishing I knew what was being said. (It’s already funny without knowing what’s being said. It’s probably hilarious knowing!) The few characters I still remembered that I could pick out every once in a while as primitives really made me want to go back and restart from the beginning, so next time I could pick out just a few more at least! It really reminded me of why I wanted to learn to read and every step closer is a step closer to being able to read those comics, not to mention everything else!

I don’t know if any of this comment gave any advice which was helpful to you at all, but as long as you’re exposing yourself to Japanese (and not hating it!), you’re on the right track!

]]>
By: JJLuke77 /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49068 Sun, 18 Jul 2010 19:22:31 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49068 I’d start with a Kana/Kanji de Manga or Kana/Kanji pict-o-graphics. It depends of whether you prefer images with english words association, or comics.
It helped me A LOT (I like more Manga :D)

]]>
By: Magdalena /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-49065 Sun, 18 Jul 2010 18:54:43 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-49065 I like the part about the basics. I realised it only not so long ago. I used to think that learning a language requires remebering some rare words. And I would daydream about knowing words like that and of course I did nothing. Some time ago I’ve heard someone say that learning a language means mastering the basics. A simple thought but how powerful. I no longer disdain practising how to say “I am” in all different ways. That definately works. Good luck for everyone learning languages with AJATT!

]]>
By: fdsfdaafsd /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48974 Sun, 18 Jul 2010 02:06:18 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48974 Wow I didn’t know people had to restart for so long. I believe the main reason that people tend to forgot to do Japanese or just leave it there is because 1. something really happened or 2. You forgot to LOVE doing Japanese. I should know been restarting for 2 years and still not fluent. I’m not a beginner but I start to feel like it when I can’t even understand simple things. I have noticed I can translate a lot of things to my friend for example Angel Beats. I don’t know why but he actually understands it through my translations.

I remember the first time I wanted to learn Japanese because I wanted to live there. I HAD to do it because I was being too hardcore and destroying everything english but not replacing it at all. These bouts of feeling not too hardcore led to me going back to a certain English channel on youtube to relieve the stress. This seemed to continued for 2 years until I finally realized in a post Khatz write to destroy EVERYTHING in enlgish but I at least replaced it with Japanese things.

Now my reasoning for learning Japanese is like a child’s thinking. “I will learn Japanese just for the cartoons and video games” was my reasoning and it worked properly. I had never had to go back to the certain channel and it’s actually been fun. Like Khatz said begin with the basics. Repeat the basics because they will come back to you. Remember you don’t have to follow Khatz advice of Japanese at all. There’s no point arguing just DO it. Do it because it’s fun and remember why your doing it. If you can’t remember just do it because it’s there simple.

Now if only I could go back to my SRS deck. I’ve been lazy to start it but I believe I will start now instead of later because I could make it fun. I don’t know how work and play could be the same thing. For language it works but I don’t know about anything else. Do whatever you like hell you could even give this up altogether but just remember have fun. It’s going to be long and you’ll have to restart but it’s a GAME. A game where you can put as many tokens into because you’ll never run out. That kind of game.

]]>
By: NDN /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48916 Sat, 17 Jul 2010 14:37:11 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48916 “Whenever I give concrete advice, people on either side of the middle ground die. People who are against the advice freak out about how “hardcore” it is, and people who are in favor of the advice kill themselves trying to follow it to the letter, even if it has parts they don’t need or like. It is this latter group — the people who will hurt themselves before they’ll break some “rule” because it’s supposedly “canon” — for whom I fear most. A lot of smart, serious, perfectionistic people are in this group, and I have to protect them from themselves (!)”

First of all, excuse me for any mistakes in my english. I’m not a native speaker so when I write too much in english (as in japanese) it’s very easy for me to get excited and start making mistakes.

Khatz, I hope I can help you a bit with your burden through this comment.

This is ONLY to all the “smart, serious, perfectionistic people” out there who try to follow EVERY concrete advice from Khatz.
Hopefully this will also prevent people from becoming like that in the future, in particular, Amphy who is just starting (again). 🙂

If we all had the same lifestyle and “genes” (not necessarily talent-related ones if there’s any such a thing. I prefer to call it environment instead of genes) as Khatz does, then we could follow his advice to the most detailed of the details. But WE DON’T. Each person has his own life (environment), his own problems. Khatz’s advices apply as long as the problems have (mostly) the same properties (e.g: how to learn to write kanji and not forget them). This should be pretty obvious so I don’t really know why there’s such a group of people trying to do everything the Khatz (not AJATT) way.

I prefer high-level/general advices because they can be easily applied to a lot of (apparently) different situations. Of course, some concrete advices show better the real nature of the thing but they’ll never give the benefit of flexibility that the general advice gives. So let’s consult Khatz’s general and concrete advices with care looking at how they apply to our own specific problems rather than taking them as rules that a god up in the sky named Khatzumoto wrote. It would simply be unfair to consider Khatz to be a god or genius without scientific proof. 🙂

In much the same way I no longer consider Newton, Einstein, Wilhelm Steinitz and many other so-called geniuses to be really geniuses. It’s enough to look at their historical background and see that their environment simply CAUSED them to have great ideas. In short, everyone is a genius if that’s the word but I prefer not to use it as it’s not real. Don’t know what else to say so 以上。

]]>
By: Jason /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48873 Sat, 17 Jul 2010 05:41:20 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48873 I was in a similar boat at the beginning of the summer. After a rough two college semesters, I looked at my SRS and realized I had well over 2000 cards waiting. I’d tried, over my winter break, mainlining those cards, and actually did manage to bring what was, at the time, a 1600+ backlog down to 0. The problem was, it was arduous, and I hated it. This time around I poked at the deck as the mood took me for a week or two, and then really sat down and looked at what I had to do. The massive amount of cards overdue were completely demoralizing, and killing any ambition to even start SRSing. So, I took an evening, turned my japanese music up loud, and dove into the deck. Anything I still remembered I kept, and any cards I was fuzzy on I reset and put on the bottom of the deck. I didn’t take any time to study, or even really try and look at what was on the cards. This was just meant to quickly sort the deck, and help me find my priority cards. It turned into a fun night, actually. Cutting through the deck so fast and rocking out to the music really made it enjoyable. In the end, I stayed up late since I was having such a good time, and filtered through the whole deck. I don’t know how many cards got saved, and how many are back to being unseen cards, but the deck is manageable again, and I don’t feel like I’m lost when I use my deck to study, anymore.
As I see it, the brain rarely forgets things outright. It just loses the links between separate data. I don’t think of the cleared cards as lost, or forgotten, or anything I once knew. They’re just cards. As I’m coming across these kanji and sentences, though, they seem to stick a lot better than the first time. It may almost have been beneficial to clear these cards out. As I come across them again, sometimes I draw new links. “Oh, that’s why this kanji, rather than that kanji, is used in this sentence.” “Oh, this shares the same radicals as that kanji, and the meanings are so similar.” An unexpected upside, but definitely something that brings me back for more.
As an aside, I kept my kanji deck organized by JLPT levels, and this helped me quite a bit with prioritizing certain cards. While it’s certainly good to have a well-rounded vocabulary, a lot of the higher-level vocabulary builds on the lower level stuff. This ties in a bit with the idea of starting from the basics [although Khatz may have a thing to say about relying on a formulaic, mandated guide, rather than learning what you find fun]. Anywhoo, don’t distract yourself with the idea that you should already know this or that, or you should be [or would have been] at a certain level by this time. You know what you know, and there’s no changing that. What matters now is what you want to know, and I don’t think that has changed from when you started learning japanese.

]]>
By: Ken /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48853 Sat, 17 Jul 2010 01:30:43 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48853 Here’s one thing I learned the hard way (which is really just another way of saying what Khatz said). If you set a goal to add new one sentence a day (yeah, I’m a little slow), and you miss both days over the weekend, then on Monday you *don’t* owe yourself 3 new sentences. You still just owe yourself one new sentence. If you try to charge yourself compound interest for every day you miss, you’ll get overwhelmed in no time. Just do one thing, today.

Also, get the kanji poster, and hang it up where it’s in your peripheral vision at work. Just glancing at it for a couple seconds every now and then seems to be a big help. (Maybe it’s like micro-SRS’ing: instead of repeating things with depth every few days, it’s repeating things very shallowly but every few minutes. Or maybe not. Who knows. I’m not a neuroscientist, I’m just some random guy on the internet.) And train your coworkers to quiz you on it!

P.S., One of my favorite American TV shows, Law & Order, doesn’t appear to have ever been dubbed into Japanese (only subtitled), so if anybody knows who I have to bribe to make that happen, please let me know. 🙂

]]>
By: Maya /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48851 Sat, 17 Jul 2010 01:20:12 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48851 I’m also re-doing kanji for the gazillionth time 🙂 To be more precise, I’m now on my 4th go at RTK, and on my 8th-ish go at kanji in general. But I’ll get there – I’m now going at the slow but steady pace of 10-15/day. I can do it 😀

It’s funny – when I first decided to learn Japanese, I was actually thinking that I’d only learn the spoken language, since I assumed it would be impossible for me to learn that many “symbols”. Now I won’t settle for anything less full literacy 😉

So there – everyone sucks/is doubting themselves at first. Just don’t let that doubt get the best of you, and you’re good to go 🙂

]]>
By: Jon /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48839 Fri, 16 Jul 2010 23:54:44 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48839 1) Delete anything you don’t understand from your deck and immediately add 5 sentences/Kanji/etc. you do understand.

2) Open up RTK to the index section. Now write out all of the primitives one by one. Do this for a week everyday in conjunction with SRSing them. (It doesn’t take long.)

3) Go get one movie you really liked in Japanese, grab some popcorn and let it wash over you. (Just don’t care if you understand anything or something.)

Why?
# Primitives are the basis of RTK. Recognizing and writing them means you can write all of the RTK Kanji.
# Get your sea legs back by doing some enjoyable listening.
# It’s going to take ages to re-remember your deck if you have a lot of items. Just delete and refresh.

Side note:
Thanks for the good article Khatz. I think that going back to basics is something I also need to take on as I’ve found myself stressing about not being good enough to talk yet. Your article really helped me and so thank you!

]]>
By: Amelia /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48819 Fri, 16 Jul 2010 20:48:49 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48819 Fall back in love with it. When I dropped French for Chinese, it was because I stopped liking France (I was living there, and China seemed nicer than where I was). But ten years later I went back to French because I thought I could just take a test in it for some cash. I took six weeks and filled my head with French, but it didn’t work, because I HATED it still. I kept missing Chinese.

When I went back to Chinese after being away from it, I felt stupid. It was harder to read books, harder to understand the sitcoms I leave running all day (丑女无敌!), harder to read the more obtuse characters and idioms I had been SRSing. But I kept at it. I left a stopwatch running all day that I started and stopped whenever I listened to Chinese and every day I wrote down my time and tried to beat it. And after a while, mysteriously, it was all easy again. I just knew what they were saying, and I LOVED it again. How could I not keep learning when it’s *the* fun thing in my day? I read martial arts novels at my break (天龙八部), listen to stupid sitcoms with my tiny iPod and tiny timer (SportCount’s ring timer), and do my SRSs on Anki for iPhone. It’s all gadgets and goofy fun. Honestly, I don’t even care if I’m learning–I’m just enjoying.

But I’m totally learning.

]]>
By: VChu /getting-back-on-the-horse-how-to-make-a-comeback-from-a-japanese-hiatus/#comment-48814 Fri, 16 Jul 2010 19:38:18 +0000 /?p=2131#comment-48814 I’m having some similar problems right now. I’ve been learning Japanese at a very slow pace due to busy schedule, but at least I was consistent. In about a year I went through almsot 1900 RTK frames and gathered around 200 sentences. I was already listening to Japanese music before that, and I got into the habit of listening to Japanese radio. However, life got in the way about 2 months ago, so I stopped RTK reviews which lead to some 600 kanji reviews piling up and me forgetting many of them. I still kept up with the sentences since there weren’t that many anyway, but I just got discouraged every time I looked at the RTK deck.

I’m slowly starting to get back on track. I set up 20 minutes per day dedicated to just RTK and however many reviews I go through, that’s that for the day. The pile is getting smaller (very slowly) and I noticed it helped if I kept switching the order in which I review (i.e. shortest interval, longest interval, order due) in Anki. This gives it some variety and lets me make sure I push the old cards as far back as I can while still getting a chance to review the ones I learned more recently.

This is probably easier than going through RTK from scratch, because even though my retention rate dropped it’s still around 70% which is much better than what I expected.

]]>